Kurka LabsFieldwork Notes

The Condiment That Should Exist

It is 2026, and there is no onion ketchup — so we wrote the recipe.

Chef Jennie in a ship's galley, squeezing a golden ribbon of onion ketchup onto a hot dog.
Chef Jennie, whose twenty-nine hot dogs were missing exactly one thing.

It is 2026, and there is no onion ketchup.

I don't mean onions on a hot dog — those are glorious and accounted for. I don't mean the red onion sauce on the New York carts, which is onions simmered in a tomato sauce, wonderful and not this. I mean the thing itself: a smooth, tangy, squeeze-bottle condiment where the onion is the base, the way tomato is the base of the red kind. Ketchup, only onion.

Check the shelf. There's onion jam, which is sweet and made for cheese. There's the cart sauce, which is a topping, not a condiment. And then there's a gap shaped exactly like a bottle.

Here's the part that got me: the gap is a pruning, not an oversight. Ketchup was once a whole family of savory sauces — mushroom ketchup, walnut ketchup, oyster ketchup lined the shelves before the tomato, a New World upstart, took the name for itself in America. The onion branch was there. It just never made the crossing. We are not inventing a condiment in 2026. We are reviving one that got left at the dock.

So we wrote the recipe. Chef Jennie — whose microwave hot-dog book holds twenty-nine dogs and not one proper sauce to crown them — has been consulted, and she approves. The short form:

The recipe, short form

Cook 3 pounds of sliced yellow onions down, low and slow, for the better part of an hour, until they're deep golden and jammy — that's where the sweetness is grown, not added. Build the ketchup: ¾ cup apple cider vinegar, a third of a cup of brown sugar, mustard powder and celery seed (the classic ketchup spice signature — your tongue will recognize the family before it notices the tomato is missing), black pepper, a pinch of clove, and a spoon of soy sauce doing quiet work. Simmer ten minutes, blend it silky, thin it to a ketchup pour, and taste for the order of events: tang first, then sweet onion.

That's it. An hour, one pot, and a condiment that pours like it always existed.

The full card

Yield: about 2 cups. Time: ~1 hour 15 minutes.

Ingredients: 3 lbs yellow onions (about 5 large), sliced thin · 2 tbsp neutral oil · 1 tsp fine salt · ¾ cup apple cider vinegar · ⅓ cup brown sugar, packed · ½ tsp mustard powder · ¼ tsp celery seed · ¼ tsp black pepper · 1 pinch ground clove · 1 tbsp soy sauce · water, to a ketchup pour.

Method: (1) Oil in a heavy pot over medium-low; onions and salt in, lid ajar; cook 45–60 minutes, stirring more toward the end, until deep golden, jammy, and reduced to about a third. A splash of water and a scrape rescues any fast browning. (2) Add vinegar, sugar, and spices; simmer 10 minutes until the sharp vinegar smell rounds out. (3) Blend completely smooth, adding water a splash at a time until it pours and ribbons like ketchup; strain for bottle-smooth. (4) Balance: tang first, then sweet onion — too sharp, a pinch more sugar; too flat, a teaspoon more vinegar and a pinch of salt. It firms slightly as it cools; bottle it a touch loose.

Serve it on: hot dogs first — that was the point — then burgers, fries, eggs, meatloaf glaze, and grilled cheese as the dip. Keeping: refrigerate 3–4 weeks; freezes 3 months. A fridge condiment — the acidity isn't lab-tested for shelf canning.

Variations: Smoky — 1 tsp smoked paprika, onions a shade deeper. Hot — one chipotle in adobo blended in. Cart-style — 2 tbsp tomato paste at the build step, a nod to the pushcarts. Vidalia — sweet onions, white wine vinegar, sugar cut to ¼ cup.

The honest footnote, because this journal keeps its receipts: the recipe is v1, written from the principles and not yet from a batch. The first pot grades it, and the verdict — good, bad, or adjusted — will be published here like everything else. If your batch teaches you something mine didn't, that's the learn-sharing pool working as designed, and I want to hear it.

One more thing, and then I'll stop marveling. We have put people back on the Moon's doorstep, we carry supercomputers in our pockets, and somewhere along the way we collectively agreed that ketchup means tomato and mustard means yellow and that was the end of the squeeze-bottle shelf. It wasn't the end. It was just where everyone stopped.

The onion was there the whole time. It only needed somebody to cook it down.

The family grew — three siblings, added the same day

The ketchup turned out to be one branch of a family, so the family got written down while the pot was still warm. Each card is v1 like its parent — written from the principles, graded by the first batch.

Onion Mustard

Short form: cook 2 lbs of sliced onions down to a deep golden jam. Off the heat — mustard's bite is volatile and dies in a boiling pot — blend the base smooth with ½ cup Dijon and a spoon of mustard powder, a quarter cup of cider vinegar, honey, and turmeric, then stir in ¼ cup whole-grain mustard by hand so the seeds stay whole. Serve it on: bratwurst and sausages, soft pretzels, ham, roast pork. Yield: about 1½ cups. Keeping: refrigerate 3–4 weeks.

Onion Sauce

Short form: melt 3 lbs of sliced onions in butter with a bay leaf and thyme, low and slow, until completely soft and pale gold — this one stays light; you're melting, not browning. A splash of white wine, a cup of stock, ten minutes more, then blend it silky: the onion's own body is the thickener, no flour. Finish with a little cream if you like, white pepper, a whisper of nutmeg, and one teaspoon of vinegar or lemon — not enough to taste sour, just enough to keep the sweetness awake. Serve it on: pork chops, sausages and mash, roast chicken, mashed potatoes — the pour-over for the whole table. This is soubise, the classic French onion sauce: proof the onion was always a sauce, never just a topping. Yield: about 2 cups. Keeping: refrigerate 4–5 days; freezes 3 months.

Onion-Ketchup-Mustard

Short form: the ketchup method, with mustard raised from seasoning to co-star — ⅓ cup Dijon and a full spoon of mustard powder at the build, turmeric for the golden color your eye expects, sugar cut back to ¼ cup because the mustard brings its own sharpness, and 2 tbsp whole-grain mustard stirred in at the end. Serve it on: hot dogs first — the whole stand in one squeeze — then burgers, brats, and fries. Ketchup and mustard never shared a bottle because tomato fights mustard; on the onion base, the fight is over — onion is the one ingredient both of them already like. Yield: about 2 cups. Keeping: refrigerate 3–4 weeks; freezes 3 months.

Receipts and editions: The recipe card (Drive, anyone-with-link): https://drive.google.com/file/d/1eswZYCIQ1LZcwST20MT3H3_GnGNkVg9x/view · The sibling cards: Onion Mustard https://drive.google.com/file/d/1rG620EQWdC8BAIhNpPILrZaz2EFe8Mr9/view · Onion Sauce https://drive.google.com/file/d/17qfhBwo40IYX5f932uFtn5mfuTBBXah5/view · Onion-Ketchup-Mustard https://drive.google.com/file/d/1TamHlaZhqNmkmNEHEczCyEL6otKh5Y-8/view · The cart-sauce neighbor, by its manufacturer's spec: Sabrett Onions in Sauce — onions, water, tomato paste, modified corn starch, salt, sugar, olive oil, fumaric acid, spices · Jennie's shelf: https://kurkalabs.dev/jennie · Editions of this Note: Substack · Beehiiv · LinkedIn · Facebook · X · Threads · Bluesky · Reddit · Medium · Instagram (links gathered here as they verify).

Fieldwork Notes is Frank's working journal. Subscribe at fieldworknotes.substack.com and the next one arrives by email.